Bitcoin vs. S&P 500: What a 50% Win Rate Means
Bitcoin matched the S&P 500 in half of recent trading sessions. See what the 90-session win rate says, what it misses and how to read the midterm data.

Bitcoin's 50% Win Rate Against the S&P 500: Signal or Noise?
Bitcoin and the S&P 500 are back on more even footing on one specific measure: which one did better in each trading session. Glassnode reports that Bitcoin outperformed the index in 50% of US trading sessions over the latest rolling 90-session period. That follows a stretch where Bitcoin won fewer sessions than it lost.
Still, a 50% win rate isn't the same thing as a sustained recovery, and it doesn't mean Bitcoin has "beaten stocks" over the full period. A win rate only tells you how often one asset's return was higher than the other's. It doesn't show how big those returns were, what kind of risk was involved, or whether the pattern is likely to stick.
The timing also lines up with renewed interest in what past US midterm elections have meant for stocks. The historical figures are interesting, but the sample is small and specific - so it's hard to treat them as a roadmap for what comes next. Here's how to read the Bitcoin comparison, what the election data actually measures, and what you'd want to check before drawing a broader conclusion.
What does a 50% Bitcoin win rate against the S&P 500 mean?
A 50% win rate means Bitcoin's return was higher than the S&P 500's in half of the measured US trading sessions. In the other half, the index did better. This is about the frequency of relative wins - not about whether Bitcoin rose in 50% of those sessions, or whether the two assets produced equal total return over the whole window.
It's worth keeping the intuition straight. You can get a 50% win rate even if Bitcoin outperforms by a small margin in 45 sessions and then falls sharply in the other 45. In that case, Bitcoin's total return could still be lower. The reverse can also happen: fewer winning sessions can still translate into a higher overall return if the wins are much larger.
Glassnode's measurement uses a rolling window of 90 US trading sessions. It also says Bitcoin's win rate hadn't been above 50% since March 2025, and that for much of the time since, Bitcoin lost more sessions to the S&P 500 than it won. So an even split is a shift from the prior pattern, not automatic proof that the relative trend has fully flipped.
Glassnode also reports that Bitcoin's average per-session gains were slightly higher than the S&P 500's in the latest measurement. That helps, but the difference is described as small. Without knowing the size and distribution of the underlying returns, it's hard to argue that Bitcoin has clearly outperformed on a risk-adjusted basis.
Why a session win rate can be useful
This kind of metric can help you see whether outperformance is coming from steady, repeated differences - or from a handful of big moves. If Bitcoin wins more often over time, that can suggest more consistent day-to-day relative strength. If it wins fewer sessions but still posts a higher total return, the story may rely more on a small set of outsized gains.
So it's useful, but it shouldn't be the whole analysis. The win rate belongs alongside cumulative return, volatility, and drawdowns - because those are the things that shape outcomes for an investor who actually holds through the period.
What the figure does not say
This number isn't a forecast, and it doesn't measure Bitcoin's standalone strength. It also isn't evidence that investors are abandoning stocks. It's simply a relative comparison: over a defined period, it records which asset's return was higher in each session. Both assets could be rising, both could be falling, or one could be flat while the other moves. The score only records the winner each time.
What does the 90-session comparison leave out?
A rolling 90-session window smooths some short-term noise, but it's still short enough that the result can change as market conditions shift. Change the start date, and you can change the answer. A small number of unusually large moves can also swing the reading.
That's why it's best treated as a snapshot of recent relative behavior - not a permanent property of either market.
There's also a timing mismatch built into the setup. The S&P 500 trades on a defined US market schedule. Bitcoin trades continuously, including weekends and US market holidays. Any comparison based on US trading sessions needs a convention for mapping Bitcoin's continuous price changes onto those sessions. That convention can affect what you see day to day, especially around weekends or fast-moving news. The comparison isn't invalid, but it's a reason to be cautious about "precision" at the daily level.
Three dimensions to check alongside win rate
If you're going to treat a 50% reading as evidence of improving performance, it helps to compare it with at least three other measures:
- Cumulative return: Over the same 90-session period, did Bitcoin end up with a higher total gain than the S&P 500, given the chosen start and end points?
- Volatility and drawdown: Did the relative advantage come with bigger swings or deeper losses? Higher return can be less attractive if the path was tougher to sit through.
- Consistency across windows: Does the improvement show up across shorter and longer periods, or only inside this one rolling window? Seeing it across time horizons matters because it's harder for the result to be a fluke.
These checks answer different questions. Cumulative return is about the outcome over the full stretch. Volatility and drawdown describe the risks along the way. Looking across windows helps test whether the conclusion depends on one specific timeframe.
Correlation is not the same as outperformance
TradingView data puts Bitcoin's rolling 20-day correlation with the S&P 500 at 0.63 over the reported period. That's a positive correlation, meaning the two assets tended to move in the same direction during that window. Correlation doesn't mean their returns were equal, or that one caused the other's moves.
Correlation and win rate are answering different questions. Correlation looks at how returns move together. Win rate looks at how often Bitcoin's return was higher. It's possible to have a positive correlation and still see Bitcoin outperform in more than half of sessions - or for the S&P 500 to win more often.
The source also notes that both crypto and stocks gained as the US Treasury expanded debt buybacks. That could be part of the broader backdrop, but it doesn't prove the policy change directly caused the performance pattern. Liquidity expectations, interest rates, and overall risk appetite can pull both markets in the same direction - raising correlation even if the assets aren't "interchangeable."
What does midterm election history say about stocks?
Capriole Investments highlights a specific historical setup: Democrats winning both the House and Senate under a Republican president. In their analysis of 26 US midterm elections since 1922, this combination happened seven times. In those cases, the S&P 500 gained an average of 10.7% over the next three months, 17.5% over six months, and 15.5% over a year.
Those averages are memorable, but they're based on just seven cases, not a dependable rule. Each period came with its own economic backdrop - growth, interest rates, policy expectations, and starting valuations. And averages don't tell you the spread of outcomes. Some windows may have produced much larger gains, while others may have been weaker or negative.
It's also conditional on a particular political outcome. The data doesn't prove that a Democratic sweep caused the subsequent market returns, and it doesn't guarantee the same pattern would hold under a different economic environment. Markets react not just to the result, but also to what they expected going into election day.
How to read the three return periods
The three-month, six-month, and one-year numbers are separate holding-period averages after the elections. They shouldn't be added together. The six-month figure isn't "three months on top of three months," and the one-year figure isn't additional return beyond the six-month window.
The differences between the averages also underline why time horizon matters. In this sample, the six-month average was higher than both the three-month and one-year averages. That doesn't prove six months is the "best" time to hold stocks after an election - it just describes what those historical calculations produced for this small set of events.
What the historical comparison cannot predict
Election statistics can add context for how markets behaved in past political cycles. They can't reliably function as a standalone trading signal. Market returns depend on more than which party controls Congress - economic growth, inflation, Federal Reserve policy, corporate earnings, and investor positioning all matter.
For Bitcoin investors, this limitation is even more important. The cited figures are S&P 500 returns, not Bitcoin returns. They may help explain why equity-market history is showing up in the current discussion, but they don't say that Bitcoin will follow the same post-election path. Bitcoin can move based on both macro conditions and factors specific to digital assets.
How should investors compare Bitcoin with equities?
First, decide what you're trying to answer with the comparison. If your question is whether Bitcoin has recently been beating large-cap US stocks more often, the win rate is relevant. If your question is which asset delivered the better return over a particular holding period, look at cumulative returns. And if your question is whether higher returns came with tougher downside, bring volatility and drawdowns into the picture.
Otherwise, you end up letting one statistic do multiple jobs. A 50% win rate is about session frequency. A positive 20-day correlation is about how returns tend to move together. The midterm figures are historical context for the S&P 500. None of these, by itself, gives a complete view of Bitcoin's risk or expected return.
A practical comparison checklist
When you see a claim about Bitcoin versus equities, check things like this:
- Confirm the dates and frequency. Is the figure based on daily, weekly, or monthly returns? Does the period cover a full market cycle or just a short stretch?
- Separate relative wins from total performance. A higher win rate doesn't automatically mean higher cumulative return - so check both.
- Look at downside as well as upside. Review maximum drawdown and volatility, not just average gains. That's crucial if you actually need to hold through the period.
- Check the benchmark and measurement convention. The S&P 500 is a large-cap US equity index. Confirm how Bitcoin's continuous trading was aligned with US market sessions, and whether the index returns include dividends.
- Test whether the result holds across time horizons. A pattern that looks clear over 90 sessions may look different over a year (or across a full cycle). Time horizon changes the answer, and you shouldn't cherry-pick the window that flatters the conclusion.
- Treat historical event studies as context. A sample of seven elections is worth examining, but it's not a forecast - and it shouldn't automatically outweigh current market and economic evidence.
What would make the Bitcoin signal more convincing?
A move back to 50% is a sign that relative performance has stabilized - but it's not yet proof of a durable break from underperformance. The signal would matter more if Bitcoin's win rate moved above 50% and stayed there across subsequent rolling windows, while cumulative performance also improved. It would be even stronger if it didn't depend on a small number of exceptional sessions.
A practical way to frame the next update is simple: watch whether the improvement persists, whether the average return advantage grows, and whether drawdowns look proportional to the gains. If the win rate rises but cumulative returns stay weak, the "recovery" may be narrower than it looks. And if returns improve while correlation stays high, it may mean Bitcoin is following the same broad risk-on environment as equities, rather than moving independently.
Conclusion
Bitcoin's return to a 50% win rate against the S&P 500 is a real change from a long period of relative weakness. But by itself, it isn't proof that Bitcoin has entered a lasting stretch of outperformance. The metric tells you how often Bitcoin won across a defined set of sessions; it doesn't capture the full return path or the risk required to hold through it.
Read it alongside cumulative performance, drawdowns, correlation, and results across different time horizons. And treat the midterm-election averages as historical context, not a forecast. The takeaway is straightforward: the data suggests Bitcoin's relative performance has stabilized, while the case for a broader recovery still needs confirmation.