Crypto Trust Firms in US Derivatives Settlement
See how CFTC relief could let crypto trust firms handle US derivatives settlements, what banks are contesting, and why the regulatory opening may not last.

Can Crypto Trust Firms Take a Role in US Derivatives Settlement?
Crypto firms are moving beyond custody and trading into parts of the financial plumbing banks have traditionally handled. One of the newest openings is daily settlement for US derivatives clearinghouses - an operational function that supports the transfer of billions of dollars when positions are marked to market and daily gains and losses get paid.
On November 5, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) issued a decision that gives clearinghouses a way to use trust companies for this work, as long as they meet the same evaluation and monitoring requirements applied to settlement banks. That could be an entry point for regulated crypto custodians who want a bigger institutional footprint. It also does not create a permanent right to participate.
That distinction matters. This is a staff no-action position, not a change to the underlying regulation. Banks remain eligible, trust companies still have to meet operational requirements, and the CFTC's view could be withdrawn. Below is what the decision changes, why firms are paying attention, and what market participants should verify before assuming this is here to stay.
Why are crypto firms interested in derivatives settlement?
Settlement isn't the most visible part of derivatives trading, but it's central to how a clearing system keeps running. A clearinghouse sits between buyers and sellers, manages their obligations, and processes payments as the value of positions changes. Settlement providers help move the funds that clear those obligations.
The scale is big. CME Group reported that its clearing systems transferred an average of $8.7 billion per business day in the first half of 2026, up from $6.7 billion a day in 2025. These figures are settlement flows, not revenue available to any one settlement provider. They mainly point to the volume the underlying infrastructure has to support, not the size of a specific firm's opportunity.
For a crypto custodian, the appeal is both strategic and financial. If a firm already safeguards digital assets and serves institutional clients, it may want to add more of the connected services those clients ask for: custody, collateral management, financing, trading, and settlement. Each added service can make a firm more useful to customers, but it also increases operational responsibilities and regulatory exposure.
The direction is already showing up in the market. Coinbase Custody Trust was expected to provide daily settlement services under Nodal Clear's arrangement with Coinbase. That integration work started after Coinbase began incorporating USDC into US futures trading in 2025. Separately, BitGo launched its Global Markets division on November 4, bringing derivatives trading, financing, collateral management, and settlement capabilities under one roof.
Still, none of that automatically means digital assets will replace bank money in clearing. The CFTC relief is about which eligible institutions can provide settlement services. A trust company being involved doesn't, by itself, prove that settlement is happening on-chain or that USDC is used for every payment.
The practical opportunity is access to a larger institutional workflow. The real test is whether a trust company can meet a clearinghouse's requirements for dependable, monitored settlement operations at scale. A charter and custody experience may help with eligibility, but they don't automatically prove the provider can handle the day-to-day demands of a clearing system.
What does the CFTC decision actually allow?
On November 5, the CFTC's Division of Clearing and Risk issued no-action relief after an October 29 request from derivatives clearinghouse Nodal Clear. The relief allows a clearinghouse to use a trust company for daily settlements if it applies the same evaluation and monitoring requirements it uses for traditional settlement banks.
At issue was a rules mismatch. Federal commodities law allows customer funds to be held at banks or trust companies, while CFTC Regulation 39.14 defines settlement banks only as banks. The staff relief gives clearinghouses a limited path to use trust companies without formally rewriting that regulation.
That limitation is key. A no-action letter generally means CFTC staff will not recommend enforcement action if the party follows the conditions in the letter. It doesn't rewrite the regulation, it doesn't guarantee approval for every trust company, and it doesn't force a clearinghouse to use one. The clearinghouse still decides whether a proposed provider meets its own operational and risk standards.
In practice, a firm looking at this route should break it into three questions:
- Is the institution eligible? Its charter and regulatory status matter, but eligibility doesn't guarantee operational readiness.
- Does the clearinghouse accept its controls? The clearinghouse has to evaluate and monitor the provider under the applicable requirements.
- Does the CFTC relief remain in effect? The staff position is conditional and can be withdrawn.
So this is a permissions pathway, not a blanket licence to conduct every bank-like activity. It's also not a claim that trust companies and banks face identical regulatory regimes in every respect. The point is narrower: for the settlement activity covered by the relief, clearinghouses may consider qualifying trust companies under the stated conditions.
That narrowness cuts both ways. It creates an opening without forcing clearinghouses to change providers or lowering their obligations. It also leaves firms tied to a regulatory position that may be less durable than a formal rule change. For operators, that should affect both contract planning and investment decisions: build to capture the opportunity, but don't assume the current interpretation will last indefinitely.
How could trust companies compete with banks?
The relief expands the list of possible providers, but it doesn't erase the advantages banks already have. Established banks have a track record serving clearinghouses, built treasury operations, and existing relationships across market infrastructure. A trust company would still need to demonstrate it can operate reliably inside the clearinghouse's control framework - rather than just point to a digital-asset charter or custody product.
Crypto firms may still bring capabilities that clearing firms find useful. Some already run digital-asset custody, support institutional clients, and offer services around collateral and trading. If a clearinghouse (or its members) wants a provider with those capabilities, a trust company could be part of the answer. The real question is whether the provider fits the workflow and can meet the required standards.
A national trust bank charter is part of the evolving landscape, but it's not the same thing as automatic access to every banking activity. Coinbase National Trust Company - separate from Coinbase Custody Trust - started operating under its charter on November 6 to provide federally supervised digital-asset custody services. Circle, Ripple, Crypto.com, and Stripe-owned Bridge have also obtained national trust bank approvals in recent months, according to reporting.
Charter status, legal entity, and service scope all matter. Companies can hold multiple regulated entities, and each one can come with different permissions and responsibilities. For customers and counterparties, the practical question isn't whether a brand has a charter. It's which legal entity provides the service, what it's authorized to do, and how the specific settlement arrangement is supervised.
Digital Chamber CEO Cody Carbone argued that the CFTC relief doesn't automatically place trust companies ahead of or behind banks. In his framing, it gives clearinghouses another option while leaving banks free to compete. That's a useful way to look at it: the regulatory change shifts the provider set, not the core business need for clearinghouses to pick providers they can trust.
Competition, then, will come down to execution. A clearinghouse will likely focus on whether a provider can meet its evaluation and monitoring standards, support steady operations, and fit within the clearinghouse's risk controls. A trust company's ability to bundle connected custody or collateral services may help - but only if those services solve a real problem without creating unacceptable operational or legal dependencies.
How durable is the regulatory opening?
The biggest uncertainty is what kind of action this is. The staff issued no-action relief rather than amending Regulation 39.14 through formal rulemaking. As attorney Jordan Yeagley told Cointelegraph, a change in Commission leadership could lead to withdrawal of the CFTC letter; a more formal Commission action would be needed to avoid that specific risk.
Withdrawal wouldn't necessarily mean every existing settlement arrangement stops overnight. What happens would depend on the terms of the letter, any additional agency actions, and the contracts and arrangements between clearinghouses and providers. But the possibility is enough to make long-term investment decisions harder. Firms need to think through what happens if the legal basis for using a trust company shifts after they've built systems, signed contracts, or taken on new operational responsibilities.
Timing also matters. CFTC Chair Michael Selig is the agency's sole commissioner, even though the statute provides for five commissioners. The November 3 US midterm elections also reshaped the political environment: Democrats won control of both chambers of Congress, and the incoming Congress takes office in January. Congress can scrutinize the agency's agenda, and the Senate plays a role in confirming nominees to fill vacant commissioner seats. The House and Senate Agriculture Committees oversee the regulator.
None of this tells you what the CFTC or Congress will do next. It does mean firms shouldn't treat the current staff position as a settled, permanent framework. Political control can affect oversight and appointments, but the outcome of any specific policy question remains uncertain.
A practical diligence checklist
Before relying on the opening, a clearinghouse, trust company, or institutional customer should work through four questions:
- What exactly does the relief cover? Confirm the proposed service falls within the letter's scope and that all stated conditions are met.
- Who is the regulated counterparty? Identify the precise legal entity, its charter, and what services it's permitted to provide.
- How will the clearinghouse evaluate and monitor the provider? Map the provider's controls to the requirements applied to settlement banks and document ongoing oversight.
- What is the fallback if the relief changes? Consider contractual remedies, operational continuity, and how settlement can transition without interrupting clearing activity.
This isn't a substitute for legal advice. It's a way to keep the commercial and operational questions in view alongside the regulatory analysis. In a market where settlement has to work every business day, a provider's ability to keep serving the clearinghouse matters as much as its ability to enter the market.
Conclusion
The CFTC's no-action relief creates a real - but bounded - opportunity for crypto trust companies in US derivatives settlement. It removes one regulatory barrier for clearinghouses that want to consider trust companies, while keeping banks able to compete and requiring the same evaluation and monitoring standards described in the relief.
The harder question is whether firms can build durable operations on a revocable staff position. For now, the sensible approach is to treat trust companies as additional potential providers - not automatic bank replacements - and to assess the legal entity, operational controls, and fallback plan before relying on this new pathway. The infrastructure may evolve quickly, but the regulatory footing is still not fully settled.