Digital Game Ownership: Why Regulation Matters
Digital-only games put resale and long-term access in question. See what GameStop’s criticism, proposed US legislation and blockchain can—and can’t—change.

Digital-Only Games Put Ownership and Access Under Pressure
When a game is sold as a download code instead of a disc, the purchase can feel basically the same. But the rights behind it often aren't. With digital codes, players may lose the ability to resell, lend, or trade the copy - and access can depend on a publisher's servers and policies. That difference matters to consumers, retailers, and anyone trying to understand what "owning" a digital game really means.
GameStop CEO Ryan Cohen has pushed the issue into the spotlight by arguing that publishers' shift away from discs harms both players and his business. His comments landed while Grand Theft Auto 6 was still widely expected to launch as a digital-first title, with boxed products containing download codes rather than a playable disc. At the same time, U.S. Representative Ritchie Torres is backing the proposed Power to the Players Act, which would require gaming companies to provide ongoing access to games consumers buy.
This debate also touches crypto, but not in the easy way - putting a game on a blockchain doesn't automatically give players ownership. The real questions are what rights a buyer actually receives, who controls access, and what happens when a company changes or shuts down a service. This article breaks down those questions and offers a practical way to judge the claims.
Why digital-only games raise an ownership problem
A physical disc isn't a perfect guarantee of permanent access. Some games still need online logins, downloads for patches, or publisher-operated servers. But a disc can still give its holder practical options that a download code often doesn't: lending it to a friend, selling it to someone else, or keeping it after a retailer stops carrying the title.
With a digital purchase, the customer may receive a license to access the game rather than an unrestricted right to possess and transfer a copy. The terms depend on the platform and the specific product. In practice, that can mean access is tied to an account, a device, a storefront, or an online service. If those systems change, the buyer may have little say in what happens next.
That's what sits underneath Cohen's objection. Speaking to Bloomberg, he argued that players should be able to sell, trade, or lend a game after buying it. His comments came as GTA 6 was being sold digitally, including through retail boxes that contain download codes. Take-Two Interactive declined to comment to Bloomberg. Cohen said GameStop sold a lot of the boxed codes, while questioning whether that arrangement gives consumers the same choice as a disc.
It's not that digital distribution is inherently bad. Downloads can be convenient, cut manufacturing and shipping, and let players start right away without visiting a store. They can also make updates easier to roll out. The trade-off is that convenience can come with less portability - and fewer ways to transfer the purchase - especially if the service behind it ends.
For consumers, the real test isn't just "Did I pay for it?" It's: What can I do with the purchase, and what happens if the platform or publisher changes its service? A purchase that can't be transferred and can become inaccessible when a company withdraws support behaves differently from a physical copy that can be played independently. That gap between "sale" language and real access conditions is where regulation and consumer expectations collide.
What GameStop's trade-in business reveals
GameStop's position isn't separate from its own incentives. Pre-owned and refurbished products are central to the retailer's model. So a move away from discs shrinks the pool of items customers can trade in - and the company can resell. That conflict doesn't automatically make Cohen's consumer argument wrong, but it does mean you should weigh his claims with his business interests in mind.
According to Bloomberg, pre-owned and refurbished products accounted for about 22% of GameStop's sales in the quarter that ended August 1, or roughly $171 million. That figure was down 32% from a year earlier. Those numbers help explain why the shift to digital is a real business problem for GameStop - not just a debate about format.
Cohen has argued that publishers benefit when used copies can't compete with new sales. In a physical market, a game can be sold more than once, with revenue flowing from the initial sale and later transactions handled by retailers. With a digital license tied to an account, resale is harder under typical platform rules. That can reduce competition from used copies and keep more purchases within the publisher's or platform's channel.
There's another side to this, though. Used markets help players recover some of the cost and give retailers a reason to accept trade-ins. They can also divert some buyers from new copies. Publishers may respond by pointing to the advantages of digital distribution - easier updates, more control over release timing, and tighter management of how content is delivered. Those points don't answer the ownership question; they explain why companies might prefer a model with fewer truly transferable copies.
Sony's announcement that it will stop producing physical discs for new PlayStation games in January 2028 adds more pressure. If fewer games remain available physically, players have fewer alternatives to account-based licenses. The impact could be bigger for people with limited broadband, tight budgets, or a preference for buying and reselling used games. Either way, the distribution model affects far more than one retailer's balance sheet.
The practical takeaway is to separate who benefits financially from what rights the buyer actually gets. GameStop has a stake in trade-ins. Publishers have a stake in digital sales. Consumers still need terms that are clear, regardless of who is making the argument.
What the Power to the Players Act could change
Cohen said he met with Representative Ritchie Torres, a New York Democrat backing the Power to the Players Act. The bill would require gaming companies to give consumers ongoing access to the titles they buy. Torres has argued that a game that can be taken away after a company "pulls the plug" isn't really a purchase.
The policy challenge is what "ongoing access" would mean in practical terms. A law could focus on stronger disclosures, require a usable offline mode, set obligations when a service shuts down, or require continued access to games people already bought. Those approaches aren't the same. Each comes with different technical and financial burdens, and each would offer a different level of protection.
Requiring that every online game run forever would be difficult to enforce. Multiplayer titles often depend on servers, moderation, security updates, and ongoing infrastructure. Keeping that going for a small number of users can be costly - and it can introduce security or safety risks. On the other hand, allowing a publisher to turn off access without any transition plan can leave customers with nothing playable, even though they paid for the game.
A workable policy discussion has to separate a game's core content from its live services. A single-player title might be supported through an offline mode or a final update. A game built around an online service might need a different end-of-life plan - advance notice, data portability where relevant, or clear disclosure before purchase. Those are the kinds of design and policy decisions lawmakers would need to consider, not assumptions about what's guaranteed.
The European Stop Killing Games campaign has collected 1.3 million signatures for a European Citizens' Initiative calling on publishers to keep games playable after support ends. It reflects a broader concern: digital purchases can depend on a service the customer can't control. The European campaign and the U.S. bill are separate efforts, but they're aimed at the same core problem.
For regulators, the goal should be meaningful consumer protection without pretending every game can be maintained indefinitely. Clear terms, realistic shutdown obligations, and disclosure before purchase are easier to assess than a vague promise of permanent access. The test ultimately comes down to whether buyers understand what they're buying - and whether companies have a reasonable, transparent plan for winding things down.
Can blockchain make digital games transferable
Blockchain is often pitched as a way to give players verifiable ownership of digital items. A token can show that a wallet controls an asset, and a public ledger can record transfers without relying entirely on one company's database. That can be useful for proving or transferring control of the token. But it doesn't, by itself, guarantee the right to play the game.
This comes down to a distinction between ownership of a record and rights to the underlying product. A token might point to a game item, a license, or some kind of entitlement - but the game still needs functioning software, servers, and a platform that recognizes what the token claims. If the publisher shuts down servers or changes the rules, a blockchain record can't magically recreate the missing service or force the company to honor the asset.
Transferability also depends on the license. A player might be able to move a token to another wallet while still being contractually barred from transferring the actual game access. Or the game's systems might not support using that asset in a recipient's account. Without enforceable terms and real technical integration, a token can be "transferable" in a narrow technical sense while still being useless to the buyer.
There are legitimate uses for blockchain in gaming - like portable inventories or verifiable transactions across systems that actually choose to support them. But those benefits require cooperation among developers, platforms, and users. They also bring the familiar concerns: wallet security, recovery options, fraud risks, transaction fees, and the basic question of whether players want to manage an on-chain asset just to access a game.
So the lesson for crypto adoption is bigger than gaming: a ledger can document a claim, but it can't create the legal or operational rights that claim relies on. Durable digital ownership needs multiple layers to work together:
- A clear legal right: the license has to spell out what the holder can use, transfer, or resell.
- Technical support: the software and platform need to recognize the transfer and keep access working.
- Operational continuity: someone still has to handle servers, updates, and shutdowns.
- A remedy when things fail: users need to know what happens if a company doesn't meet its obligations.
Without those pieces, blockchain can improve recordkeeping while leaving the core ownership problem untouched. It can be a tool inside the system - not a substitute for the system.
How gamers and investors should assess the issue
For players, the best response is to read carefully before buying - especially if the game is digital-only or heavily dependent on online services. Store pages and license terms don't always spell out every limitation clearly, but a short checklist can surface the biggest risks.
Before purchasing, ask:
- Is the product a disc, a download, or a box containing a download code?
- Is access tied to a specific account or platform?
- Does the game require the publisher's servers for its core features?
- Can the purchase be transferred, resold, or lent under the terms?
- What happens to access if the store closes or online support ends?
- Is there an offline mode, and does it require an initial connection or periodic checks?
These questions don't mean you should automatically avoid digital games. They just make the trade-off explicit. If convenience and instant access matter more than resale, a digital purchase may be the right choice. If you want to lend or resell, or you care about keeping a game playable without an ongoing service, a physical copy may give you more control - assuming the game itself doesn't depend on online infrastructure.
Investors should apply the same kind of discipline to company claims. GameStop's criticism lines up with its exposure to the second-hand market. Publishers may benefit from direct digital distribution, but they also face trust and regulatory risks when access terms are unclear or when customers feel they can be locked out after purchase. The business question isn't only which format drives more revenue today - it's whether the model holds up when customer expectations and laws shift.
For crypto investors and builders, this is a good way to test tokenization claims. Ask what the token actually controls, who recognizes it, what happens if the company stops operating, and whether the rights are enforceable beyond the platform. If the answer is only that the item exists on a blockchain, the key access question still hasn't been answered.
A simple framework helps: identify the right, identify who can revoke or restrict it, and identify what the remedy is if access ends. That works for games, digital media, and tokenized products. It keeps the conversation focused on outcomes for users - not on whether the underlying technology is "new" or "decentralized."
Conclusion
Digital-only distribution is convenient, but it can shrink what a buyer can do after paying. GameStop's trade-in exposure helps explain why it opposes the shift. Meanwhile, the Power to the Players Act and the Stop Killing Games campaign show that access after purchase is also a real consumer-policy issue.
Blockchain may help prove or transfer a digital claim, but it can't replace licensing rights, working software, or a plan for when services end. The useful question isn't whether a purchase is digital or on-chain. It's whether the buyer's rights are clear, usable, and durable - and what happens when the company behind them changes direction.