NovaTech Crypto Fraud: New York Seeks $1.37B13 min read2,636 words

NovaTech Crypto Fraud: New York Seeks $1.37B

New York is seeking $1.37 billion from NovaTech’s founders after an alleged crypto investment fraud. Learn how it worked, who was targeted and what comes next.

NovaTech crypto fraudcrypto regulationcrypto investment scamNew York Attorney Generalcrypto investor protection
NovaTech Crypto Fraud: New York Seeks $1.37B

NovaTech Case: New York Seeks $1.37 Billion From Crypto Platform Founders

A promised return of 2% to 4% every week is hard to ignore. It also raises the basic questions investors should ask right away: how those returns are generated, who controls the money, and what happens when withdrawals start outpacing new deposits.

Those questions sit at the centre of New York's case against NovaTech, a collapsed crypto trading platform accused by state regulators of taking in more than $1 billion from investors through a scheme built on high return promises and recruitment. New York Attorney General Letitia James is asking a court to order the company, its founders Cynthia and Eddy Petion, and related entities to pay about $1.37 billion. James says the founders left the United States.

The request follows an August 2025 default judgment against the Petions, but a court order and actual repayment are not the same thing. This article lays out what New York says happened, how the scheme allegedly attracted investors, what the latest settlements mean, and why the case matters if you're evaluating a crypto opportunity.

What New York is asking the court to order

New York Attorney General Letitia James is seeking approximately $1.37 billion from NovaTech, its founders Cynthia and Eddy Petion, and related companies. In the filing, James asks a New York County Supreme Court judge to order payment of damages, disgorgement and interest. That number is a request for relief, not proof that the state has already recovered the money.

The request follows an August 2025 default judgment against the Petions. A default judgment is entered when a party fails to respond to a lawsuit or otherwise defend the case. It can resolve liability, but it does not automatically locate assets, make money available to victims, or ensure the judgment can be collected. James says the founders fled the country before the judgment.

The amount sought and what it represents

According to the filing, CoinPayments recorded roughly $1.16 billion in cryptocurrency deposits to a NovaTech wallet from August 2019 through May 2023. New York says Cynthia Petion was the only authorised user on that account, and at least $134.5 million went to wallets belonging to the Petions.

New York also says NovaTech sent just under $26 million to its trading provider between 2019 and 2023, and that the provider lost about $18.2 million. After accounting for funds sent for trading, the state is seeking about $1.13 billion in disgorgement, plus roughly $232 million in interest. Those figures add up to the headline request of $1.37 billion.

Disgorgement is meant to recover gains tied to alleged wrongdoing, and interest is meant to reflect the time value of money and the period when investors were without their funds. Neither category is the same thing as cash already sitting in a compensation fund. The real question is what assets can be identified, reached legally, and distributed.

Separate actions and outcomes

This case has moved through more than one regulator and more than one legal process. James first sued NovaTech and AWS Mining in June 2024, alleging investors had been defrauded of more than $1 billion. Two months later, the US Securities and Exchange Commission charged the Petions and others over what it described as a $650 million fraud. The state and federal figures come from separate proceedings and should not be treated as the same calculation.

New York also announced settlements totalling nearly $6 million with four promoters: Martin Zizi, Frantz Ciceron, Ricardo Roy Sr. and James Corbett. The money is intended to benefit victims. The announcement also says the promoters are permanently barred from the securities, commodities and cryptocurrency industries.

That is different from the much larger amount New York is seeking from the founders and related entities. Settlements with promoters do not show that victims have received payment, and they do not resolve every claim connected to the platform. For more context on the filing and announcements, see Decrypt's report on the NovaTech case and the New York Attorney General's office.

How NovaTech allegedly attracted and paid investors

New York says NovaTech presented itself as a registered hedge fund broker authorised to trade cryptocurrency in the United States. It allegedly advertised returns of 2% to 4% per week. Depending on how the returns are calculated and compounded, that could translate to more than 140% annually.

The state says the pitch combined two things investors tend to trust: the idea of professional financial management and the promise of recurring, exceptional income. New York also alleges that the trading activity behind those claims did not generate enough money to support the promised payouts.

A community-based recruitment model

According to the attorney general's office, NovaTech and its promoters reached immigrant communities - particularly Haitian New Yorkers - through prayer groups, social media and WhatsApp chats. The marketing used Haitian Creole and religious messaging. The state says more than 11,000 New Yorkers were among the hundreds of thousands of investors worldwide.

Community networks can make an opportunity easier to discover and easier to trust. A recommendation from someone in a congregation, a family network, or a local group can carry more weight than an unfamiliar online ad. That trust can help a legitimate service reach people. But it can also be used to lower the scrutiny that normally comes with financial products.

The use of religious or immigrant communities is not, by itself, proof that those communities are more vulnerable to fraud. The key issue in the allegations is how promoters allegedly operated - using trusted settings and familiar communication channels to build confidence in claims that investors might otherwise challenge.

What the money trail allegedly shows

New York says NovaTech's weekly payouts and recruitment bonuses were funded by deposits from newer investors, not by trading profits. That distinction matters because a scheme that pays early withdrawals can look similar to a real investment for a while. New referral bonuses and initial payouts can be credited even when the underlying activity doesn't generate enough income to keep up with the promise.

New York's account is straightforward: roughly $1.16 billion in crypto deposits moved through a NovaTech wallet, while less than $26 million was sent to the trading provider during the period described in the filing. The state says the trading provider lost about $18.2 million. In New York's view, the gap between total deposits and the amount sent for trading is central to the claim that the advertised returns were not supported by actual investment performance.

These numbers are allegations laid out by the state, not a complete audit of every transaction or a final accounting of what every investor lost. Still, they help explain why investigators focus on custody, cash flows and independent verification - rather than just marketing claims or reported balances.

The earlier AWS Mining connection

New York says the Petions also promoted AWS Mining, which promised monthly returns of 15% to 20% from cryptocurrency mining before collapsing in 2019. The New York filing says Cynthia Petion told people in a WhatsApp chat that she had made at least $3 million from that earlier scheme.

The earlier venture is part of the state's picture of the promoters and their history. It is not proof of the specific claims in the NovaTech case. Investors should look at the particular entity, the people involved, the custody setup and the revenue model - rather than assuming that one project's failure automatically proves later allegations, or that a new company is safe just because it is presented as separate.

Why the case is difficult to resolve

A large judgment gets headlines because it puts a number on alleged harm. For an investor, though, the real number is what can actually be recovered and distributed. Those two things are not the same.

If defendants are outside the country, assets are split among multiple entities or wallets, or funds were moved, enforcement can take time and may depend on cooperation across jurisdictions. Crypto activity can be traceable on a blockchain, but tracing a transaction doesn't automatically identify who controls a wallet or give a court direct access to the assets. Collection depends on legal authority, evidence, custody arrangements and practical recovery steps.

New York's claim that the Petions left the country adds to the collection challenge, but it doesn't tell you where the founders are, what assets still exist, or what share could realistically be recovered. Those details shouldn't be inferred just from the amount being requested.

A judgment is not the same as restitution

There are several steps between a legal order and money reaching an investor:

  1. A court determines what relief is legally available and against whom.
  2. Enforcement efforts try to reach assets under applicable law.
  3. Recovered funds are managed and distributed through the relevant process.
  4. Investors may have to meet deadlines or provide evidence to establish claims.

This process can get complicated by competing claims, incomplete records and assets that can't be recovered. The settlements with the four promoters may add some funds for victims, but the nearly $6 million announced there is far below the roughly $1.37 billion New York is seeking from the founders and related entities. In other words, it's only one part of the overall story - not a promise of full repayment.

For investors, the practical move is to track official updates and keep your own records. Helpful documents can include deposit confirmations, wallet addresses, transaction hashes, account statements, messages with promoters and withdrawal records. If you're affected, rely on instructions from the relevant authorities or get advice from qualified legal counsel, not on unsolicited offers promising recovery for a fee.

Why regulatory claims should be read carefully

Regulatory announcements often bundle allegations, court orders, settlements and requested remedies together. Those pieces have different legal meanings. In NovaTech's case, the state's allegations about marketing and fund flows need to be kept separate from the default judgment against the Petions, the SEC's separate charges and the promoters' settlements.

That's not just technical nitpicking. It helps a reader understand what was alleged, what was decided, what a party agreed to pay and what still has to be collected. When coverage flattens all of those steps into one headline, investors can walk away thinking a requested sum has already been awarded - or already recovered.

The SEC's enforcement resources and the New York Attorney General's office are good places to check official updates. For any specific claim, read the regulator's description and the court outcome rather than relying only on a promotional post or a social-media summary.

What investors can learn from the NovaTech allegations

No checklist can guarantee an investment is legitimate. But it can help you spot when the burden of proof is being pushed from the promoter to the investor. A real pitch should be verifiable before you send money - not something that only gets clarified after withdrawals stop.

Treat unusually high fixed returns as a due-diligence trigger

A promise of 2% to 4% weekly returns isn't proof of fraud by itself. It is a reason to ask harder questions. What strategy produces those returns? Who independently verifies performance? Are returns presented before or after fees? Can the company show audited financial statements, and can it explain losses as clearly as it explains gains?

The promoter should be able to answer with documentation. A vague explanation about proprietary trading, secret strategies or "guaranteed" market insight is not verification. If the returns depend on recruiting more people into the platform, that's a separate risk you should understand before investing.

Verify status independently

If a company says it is registered, licensed or authorised, check that claim with the relevant regulator. Don't rely on a logo, a screenshot or a link provided by whoever is selling the investment. Look up the regulator's own records and confirm that the registered entity, the people involved and the activities match what the company says it does.

Registration doesn't automatically mean the investment is safe. Still, a mismatch between what the company claims and what official records show is a strong reason to pause and seek independent advice.

Understand who controls the assets

Ask where deposits are held, who controls the wallets or accounts, and whether investor funds are segregated from operating money. If a single person controls a wallet that holds investor deposits, that can be a serious custody risk. And if the platform can't explain how investors withdraw funds - or what happens in insolvency - you don't yet have the full picture.

The NovaTech allegations also show why it matters to connect deposits to what happens next. A platform can have polished branding and accept crypto payments without proving that most of the funds are being traded in the way it claims.

Separate social proof from evidence

Friends, family members, community leaders and online testimonials may show that other people trust a promoter. They don't prove that the investment generates the returns claimed. Ask for evidence you can verify independently, and give yourself enough time to review it without pressure.

A simple rule: pause when an opportunity combines exceptional returns, urgency, recruitment incentives and a heavy reliance on personal trust. Each element might have a legitimate explanation in a different context. Together, they raise the cost of being wrong and make independent verification more important.

Conclusion

The NovaTech case is a reminder that a headline "judgment amount" and actual investor recovery are two different measures of an enforcement effort. New York is seeking about $1.37 billion, while the founders are reported to have left the country. Four promoters have agreed to settlements totalling nearly $6 million and are permanently barred from the relevant financial and crypto industries. What can ultimately be recovered is still a separate question.

For investors, the practical lesson is to verify the business behind the promise: how returns are generated, where assets are held, who controls them, and whether regulatory claims can be confirmed independently. If you think you were affected, keep your transaction and communication records and follow updates from official authorities. Don't pay an unsolicited "recovery service" to retrieve funds without checking whether the service is legitimate.

Frequently Asked Questions

New York Attorney General Letitia James is asking the court to order NovaTech, Cynthia and Eddy Petion, and related companies to pay about $1.37 billion. The request includes approximately $1.13 billion in disgorgement and $232 million in interest. It is an amount sought, not a statement that the money has been collected.
The source information does not establish that investors have been repaid. New York announced settlements totalling nearly $6 million with four promoters, with the money intended to benefit victims. Recovery from the founders and distribution to individual investors are separate steps, and the amount recovered may differ from the amount requested.
According to New York, NovaTech marketed itself as a registered hedge fund broker authorised to trade crypto in the United States and advertised returns of 2% to 4% per week. The state alleges that investor deposits and recruitment bonuses funded payouts, rather than profits from successful trading.
New York says promoters used prayer groups, social media and WhatsApp to reach immigrant communities, particularly Haitian New Yorkers. The state alleges that marketing included Haitian Creole and religious messaging. These channels can build trust within a community, which is why investors should verify financial claims independently even when an opportunity comes through someone they know.

Related articles