SEC Crypto Rules: Bitwise and Hyperliquid Seek Changes
Bitwise and Hyperliquid want clearer SEC rules for tokens, airdrops and trading. Understand the proposal, legal objections and what comes next for crypto.

The SEC's Crypto Rulebook Has a Problem: The Industry Wants Clearer Lines
Crypto firms don't always agree on regulatory questions. But Bitwise Asset Management and the Hyperliquid Policy Center say the same thing is going wrong in the SEC's proposed crypto rules: key questions about whether tokens are securities and how they can be traded are still left hanging.
Their comments came as the public comment period for the proposed Regulation Crypto Assets was ending. The SEC's proposal would create exemptions for some crypto fundraising and a conditional safe harbor for certain tokens tied to investment contracts. Bitwise wants clearer standards that investment managers can use when they're trying to determine whether tokens fall under securities laws. Hyperliquid wants a broader safe harbor and more direct guidance on airdrops, buybacks, and secondary-market trading.
This isn't the same as asking the SEC to walk away from securities regulation. It's a push for rules that can actually be applied consistently in the real situations crypto companies face. At the same time, former SEC enforcement official John Reed Stark and Duke University scholar Lee Reiners argue the proposal should be withdrawn, warning that it could exceed the agency's authority and weaken investor protections.
This article breaks down what the proposal would do, what the commenters want changed, and why the dispute matters to crypto projects, investment managers, and trading venues.
What the SEC's proposal is trying to do
The SEC's proposed Regulation Crypto Assets aims to lay out a more specific regulatory framework for parts of the crypto market. Based on the public submissions, it would create exemptions for qualifying crypto fundraising and a conditional safe harbor for certain tokens associated with investment contracts.
The distinction is important, but it doesn't settle the bigger questions by itself. A fundraising exemption addresses when a project can raise capital without going through the full set of requirements that apply to securities offerings. A safe harbor offers conditional protection for tokens in specified circumstances. Neither one, standing alone, answers every question about a token's legal status, how it can be traded, or what obligations apply to the businesses involved.
That's where the debate largely sits. A token might be sold during a fundraising effort, later distributed to users, and then traded between parties that never deal directly with the original issuer. Any regulatory approach has to account for those stages without pretending they're all the same legally or economically.
Why token status can be difficult to assess
A lot of the SEC's approach to crypto securities questions has leaned on existing securities law, including the Howey test. In broad terms, that test is used to evaluate whether an arrangement amounts to an investment contract. The analysis depends on the facts and circumstances - so a token's technical design or label usually doesn't end the inquiry on its own.
That flexibility can help when new products don't fit neatly into old categories. But it also makes day-to-day decisions harder for firms that need to classify assets before investing, listing, or building services around them. Even when the legal standard is familiar, market participants may still disagree about what evidence matters most in a specific situation.
The SEC's proposal appears to be trying to reduce that friction for some participants. But a "new route" only helps if the conditions are clear enough to apply, the relevant parties can actually determine whether they're met, and the framework is legally defensible.
The proposal is not yet a final rule
The comment period is part of the rulemaking process, not the finish line. The SEC still has to review submissions before deciding whether to revise, adopt, or withdraw the proposal. The agency hasn't announced a timetable for a final decision, and a final rule would require a commission vote before it can take effect.
So there's still room for changes. Businesses also shouldn't treat the proposal as a settled compliance playbook. A proposed exemption or safe harbor isn't a guarantee that a particular token or transaction will qualify.
The source report on the comment letters summarizes the positions submitted by Bitwise, Hyperliquid, and the proposal's legal critics.
What Bitwise and Hyperliquid want clarified
Bitwise and Hyperliquid aren't making the exact same argument. Their requests focus on different parts of a crypto asset's lifecycle: how investment managers classify tokens, how a project's ties to an investment contract might shift over time, and how tokens move through trading venues and onchain protocols.
What they share is a practical worry. If a rule can't be followed using the information the people are expected to use it, uncertainty doesn't really disappear - it just gets rebranded as "more precise" legal wording.
Bitwise: a usable standard for investment managers
In its October 19 comment letter, Bitwise asked the SEC to clarify how investment managers should determine whether a crypto asset is subject to securities laws. Bitwise's core point is that managers need a standard they can apply using publicly available information.
That has real operational consequences. An investment manager may not have access to an issuer's internal records, private legal analysis, or development plans. If the classification turns on facts the manager can't reasonably obtain, the manager is left choosing among avoiding the asset, taking on legal uncertainty, or relying on an interpretation that could later be challenged.
Bitwise also asked for clearer guidance on the proposed Form TR process. As described in the comment letter, the filing would be used to certify that an investment contract has ceased to exist. Bitwise wants to know when investment managers can rely on that filing, and how they should assess a token if there's no filing to point to.
This isn't only about whether a filing exists. It's about evidentiary weight, who can rely on it, and what happens if the underlying facts change. Without clearer answers, firms may end up applying different internal standards to similar assets. That drives up compliance costs and makes investment decisions harder to explain to clients and regulators.
Hyperliquid: address airdrops and secondary markets directly
The Hyperliquid Policy Center argued that the proposed safe harbor could end up being available too late in a project's development. A framework that only becomes helpful after a difficult stage is already over may not do much for teams trying to plan responsibly from the beginning.
The group also asked for clearer protections for airdrops that reward network participation, plus guidance on token buybacks. Those tools can serve different purposes. An airdrop might distribute tokens to users who helped build or use a network. A buyback might be part of a token-management approach. You can't resolve the legal treatment just by applying the same label to every example - the surrounding facts and incentives matter.
Hyperliquid's broader concern is that the SEC's proposal doesn't clearly address whether unregistered intermediaries can facilitate token trading, or whether tokens can trade freely through onchain protocols. It asked the SEC to address secondary-market transactions directly, rather than leaving exchanges and decentralized trading venues to operate against an unclear boundary.
That boundary matters beyond the venue itself. If a platform can't tell whether facilitating a specific trade triggers regulatory obligations, it may limit access, adjust its product, or avoid certain assets altogether. If it moves forward without confidence, it could face enforcement or litigation risk. For users, that can translate into less predictable access to liquidity and fewer consistent protections across venues.
Why legal experts oppose the proposal
Bitwise and Hyperliquid's requests assume that revising the rule would make the framework more workable. Stark and Reiners take a tougher stance: they urged the SEC to withdraw the proposal entirely.
In an October 16 comment letter, Stark and Reiners argued that the proposal goes beyond the SEC's statutory authority and could weaken investor protections. Their objection isn't only that particular terms need clarification. It's that the SEC may be creating exemptions and protections that, in their view, aren't supported by the law Congress gave the agency.
The argument for using existing securities law
Stark and Reiners say existing securities laws - together with the Howey test - already provide a framework for evaluating crypto offerings. Under that view, building on blockchain technology doesn't automatically require a whole new regulatory regime. The analysis should focus on the economic arrangement and the surrounding facts.
They have a point here: it avoids assuming that a technology-specific rule is automatically better than established law. Courts and practitioners already have tools for applying existing tests to new products, and a separate framework can create its own odd incentives - like companies restructuring to fit the rule - or create conflicts with other requirements.
Still, relying on existing law can leave the kind of uncertainty that industry participants point to. Fact-specific legal analysis is hard to apply across an entire portfolio, a trading platform, or a decentralized protocol. Familiar tests don't always translate into clear, consistent business decisions.
The concerns about exemptions and self-certification
The critics argue that the proposed fundraising exemptions could reduce protections available to investors. They also warn that a safe harbor built on issuer self-certification could let issuers move tokens out of securities oversight without an adequate independent review.
That raises a design question: who decides the conditions for relief are met, and what happens if that decision is wrong? If issuer assessments carry too much weight, investors and other market participants may have limited ways to test the claim. If the process is too demanding or too uncertain, the safe harbor may be hard to use - and may fail to solve the problem it's intended to address.
Stark and Reiners also warned that adopting the rules substantially as proposed could invite an immediate legal challenge. A court could ultimately uphold or reject the framework, and the comment letter is not a ruling. Even so, litigation risk is a serious consideration for businesses building systems around a rule that might later change - or get struck down.
What the debate could mean for crypto markets
This isn't just wordsmithing. It affects how firms assess assets, how projects plan token distributions, and whether trading venues will support certain activities. The practical impact depends on the final text and how the SEC applies it, but some consequences are already fairly predictable.
For investment managers: document the reasoning
Eventually, a new rule could create a more repeatable way to classify assets. Until then, investment managers shouldn't treat a proposed filing or an issuer's description as the final answer. What they need is a documented process - what they looked at, what assumptions they made, and what could change the analysis.
The goal isn't to manufacture certainty where the law doesn't provide it. The goal is consistency and clarity about why a decision was made. Managers should pay close attention to whether the key information is public, whether it can be independently verified, and whether the token's circumstances have materially changed since the original assessment.
For projects: plan around the full token lifecycle
A project's regulatory exposure doesn't automatically end once a token is first distributed. Fundraising, allocations, rewards, governance, buybacks, and secondary-market activity can all raise different questions. Teams that only plan for the initial launch may find that the rules around trading and ongoing communications matter just as much later on.
That doesn't mean every project should avoid token distribution or every airdrop. It does mean the rationale and the mechanics should be considered together. Who receives tokens? What activity is being rewarded? What expectations are created? How does the project describe future development? Those details can matter as much to a legal assessment as the name attached to a transaction.
For exchanges and DeFi: uncertainty has a product cost
A centralized exchange or decentralized trading venue has to decide which assets and activities it will support. Regulatory uncertainty can affect listing choices, access controls, disclosures, and even product design. Smaller teams may feel the impact more sharply, since they have less room to build separate workflows or to get deep legal advice for every asset.
For DeFi, the issue can be especially concrete. A protocol may let users interact directly with smart contracts, but other parties may provide interfaces, liquidity, or related services. The legal analysis may differ across those roles. Hyperliquid's request for more direct guidance reflects a worry that a rule aimed at issuers may leave the people and systems enabling secondary trading without a clear answer.
A decision framework for businesses
For now, businesses can work through the proposal using four questions:
- Is the rule final? A proposal isn't a compliance program. Follow the SEC's review and any revised text.
- Who is expected to rely on it? Separate issuer obligations from the decisions managers, exchanges, developers, and users make.
- What evidence supports the classification? Check whether the relevant facts are public, current, and independently verifiable.
- What happens if the rule is challenged? Think about whether the business can adapt if the final rule changes, is delayed, or faces litigation.
This isn't a substitute for legal advice. It's a way to avoid building operations around assumptions that haven't survived rulemaking - or court scrutiny - yet.
Conclusion: clarity depends on the details
The SEC is being asked to solve two different problems at once. Industry commenters want rules that can guide real decisions about token classification, airdrops, and secondary trading. Legal critics question whether the SEC has the authority to create the proposed framework and whether the exemptions would preserve investor protections.
The outcome isn't decided yet. The real test will be whether a final framework gives market participants standards they can apply while still preserving meaningful oversight and passing legal scrutiny. Until then, treat the proposal like something in progress: document your decisions carefully and don't assume a safe harbor or exemption applies just because it looks like the right label.
If you're building a crypto product or setting an investment strategy, you should review the proposed framework with counsel and map where your decisions depend on token classification or secondary-market rules. That's a more reliable starting point than banking on a rule that hasn't been finalized.