Tokenized Stocks: IMF Finds Demand and Risk14 min read2,731 words

Tokenized Stocks: IMF Finds Demand and Risk

Tokenized stocks trade around the clock, but IMF data show higher volatility and weaker liquidity. Explore what the findings mean for investors and regulators.

tokenized stockstokenized equities24/7 stock tradingfractional stock ownershipcrypto regulation

Tokenized Stocks Are Trading Beyond Wall Street Hours. The Risks Are Still Real.

If you're used to the opening bell, tokenized stocks feel different. Instead of waiting for U.S. exchanges to open, some venues keep trading after hours - so activity can continue when traditional markets are shut. The question is whether that extra access comes with extra baggage.

In its latest Global Financial Stability Report, the International Monetary Fund found that more than half of the trading in the tokenized equities it studied happened outside regular U.S. market hours. It also reported that about 80% of trades involved less than one share, which fits with demand for fractional exposure.

Still, "trading outside hours" doesn't automatically mean a healthy, mature market. The IMF found tokenized equities were about 1.5 times more volatile than their traditional counterparts and substantially less liquid. When the next regular market session opened, conventional shares absorbed most of the overnight price movement seen in their tokenized versions - suggesting the onchain activity wasn't purely random. But it also suggests investors can be exposed to thinner liquidity and bigger price swings during the off-hours window.

Here's what the IMF measured, what it didn't prove, and what investors and regulators should watch next.

What the IMF found about tokenized stocks

The IMF looked at five of the most liquid tokenized U.S. equities across 11 trading venues over 365 days. The study included tokens tracking Tesla, Nvidia, and the S&P 500. In other words: this is an early market with a limited sample - not every tokenized security, every blockchain, or every platform.

Three findings stand out:

  • Trading doesn't stop when U.S. exchanges close. More than 50% of the tokenized stock trading in the sample took place outside regular U.S. market hours.
  • Small trades are common. About 80% of trades were for less than one share. That lines up with retail investors wanting smaller chunks of exposure, though trade size alone can't explain why each person traded.
  • Token prices moved more sharply and traded less deeply. The IMF estimated tokenized equities were about 1.5 times more volatile than the underlying stocks and less liquid, especially on decentralized exchanges.

The IMF also found evidence that onchain prices weren't just noise. When traditional markets reopened, conventional shares absorbed between 87% and 99% of the overnight price moves recorded by their tokenized counterparts. So in this sample, a lot of what moved onchain showed up again once the regular market resumed.

That doesn't mean token prices always lead, or that every overnight move is accurate. It means that during the period studied, token price changes generally corresponded with what happened in the underlying stocks afterward.

The market's size and structure matter too. The IMF put it at about $2.3 billion, with products from Ondo Finance and Backed Finance's xStocks accounting for more than 70%. The report describes these products as synthetic tokens that provide price exposure without direct ownership of the underlying shares.

Concentration is common in young markets - but it changes how you should read the data. Results from a few relatively liquid products can't tell us how a much larger market would behave during a severe shock, a technology outage, or a sharp selloff in the underlying stocks. The IMF itself warned that its findings should be interpreted carefully because the market is still early. Read the IMF's Global Financial Stability Report and the report coverage for more context.

What the numbers say about market maturity

One way to make sense of the findings is to separate demand, price discovery, and market quality. The off-hours trading and frequent sub-share trades point to demand for different access and smaller trade sizes. The link between overnight token prices and the next regular-market move suggests token prices can reflect information.

But the volatility and lower liquidity point to a market that still isn't as robust as the established market it tracks.

A key point: a product can attract users and produce informative prices without offering deep liquidity or equivalent investor protections. If you treat activity as proof of maturity, you end up collapsing those differences - and taking risks you didn't intend to take.

Why 24/7 trading creates both demand and risk

Traditional U.S. stock markets have set trading hours. News doesn't. Companies can release information, geopolitical events can unfold, and major economic reports can land while the exchange is closed. Tokenized stocks give some venues a way to trade through that gap, which can be helpful if you want to adjust exposure without waiting.

Fractional trading is also a practical draw. If you can't - or don't want to - buy a whole high-priced share, trading a smaller amount can reduce the cash needed for a position. That said, fractional exposure doesn't automatically make the investment safer, cheaper overall, or equivalent to owning part of a conventional share. Fees, spreads, product terms, and legal structure still matter.

The trade-off is liquidity. A market running around the clock doesn't have to look like an exchange's main session. When the underlying U.S. market is closed, there may be fewer buyers and sellers. In a thin market, even a relatively small order can shift the quoted price more than it would during regular hours. And if you need to exit quickly, there may not be enough liquidity at the price you'd like.

That's one reason tokenized products can show higher volatility than the stock they track. It doesn't necessarily mean the reference asset suddenly became more volatile. It can also reflect the token market's own depth and how well it connects to the underlying market while that market is closed.

DEXs add another layer. The IMF found token prices on decentralized exchanges diverged more from traditional markets. A DEX can facilitate trades without a conventional order book, but limited liquidity still affects what price you actually get. When liquidity is shallow, the price you see may be less dependable as an execution price.

A price is not the same as an executable price

A displayed price is only part of the story. Investors also care about whether they can buy or sell in size at that price, how wide the bid-ask spread is, and what the token is designed to track. In a less liquid market, a price that works for a small trade might not hold for a bigger one.

Around-the-clock trading makes these differences more important, not less. A token can keep trading even when the underlying stock market isn't open, but the reference market isn't necessarily validating that quote continuously. Off-hours, price gaps can widen. When the regular market reopens, token and stock prices may converge - or a token holder may find that the overnight "price" doesn't translate into a practical execution at scale.

So the practical question for investors isn't only, "Can I trade now?" It's: "Can I trade the amount I need, at a price I understand, under rules that stay clear if markets move fast?"

What tokenized stocks do - and do not - give investors

The phrase tokenized stock can make it sound like a share was simply put on a blockchain. In practice, products vary in legal structure and in what rights they actually provide. The IMF described the products it studied as synthetic tokens that provide price exposure without direct ownership of the shares. That's something you should verify per product, not assume from the name.

A token that tracks a stock's price isn't automatically the same as holding that stock through a brokerage account. Depending on the product's terms, a token holder may not have the same shareholder rights tied to registered share ownership - for example, voting rights. The issuer, the entity responsible for issuing or redeeming tokens, and how the underlying assets are held or referenced can all affect what the customer really has.

This isn't a technical detail you can ignore. If the token issuer, platform, or supporting arrangements fail, the token holder's rights depend on the legal documents and applicable rules - not on the fact that the asset exists on a blockchain. Blockchain records can help transfer tokens, but they don't automatically guarantee a claim on a company's shares or protect investors from intermediary failure.

Before trading, a careful investor should get clear on:

  • What the token represents: direct ownership, a contractual claim, synthetic price exposure, or something else.
  • Who issues and supports it: and what happens if that entity can't meet its obligations.
  • Which rights apply: including voting rights and whether dividends are owed.
  • How the price is maintained: including what happens when the underlying market is closed.
  • Where and how it trades: custody arrangements, fees, redemption rules, and the platform/blockchain risks.

This checklist applies whether the token trades on a centralized venue or a DEX. The venue can affect execution and custody, but it doesn't remove the need to understand the asset's legal structure. And fractional exposure doesn't mean fractional risk. A small position can still be hit by a sharp price move, a wide spread, or a breakdown in the product's operating arrangements.

As the market grows, it's tempting to compare new launches by headline features - supported blockchain, available tickers, trading hours, minimum order size. Those details can matter for convenience, but they aren't enough to evaluate the investment. A better approach is to understand the claim first, the trading mechanics second, and the interface convenience last.

What regulators and market operators should watch next

The IMF said systemic risks look limited for now, largely because the market is small. That's about today's scale, not a guarantee about the future. If tokenized equities grow, become more connected to traditional finance, or rely on a small set of issuers and venues, problems that seem manageable now could become more consequential.

The report urged regulators to consider circuit breakers for 24/7 trading and to monitor connections between tokenized and traditional markets. Circuit breakers are meant to pause or constrain trading after sharp moves. Applying them in a system that never closes isn't a simple copy-and-paste job: operators would need rules for when the mechanism triggers, how it works across venues, and what happens when the underlying stock exchange is closed.

Coordination is a big part of this. A token might trade on multiple venues, while the reference share trades on a conventional exchange during its hours. If one venue pauses while another doesn't, prices and access can drift. And if token pricing depends on signals from traditional markets, operators also need to consider what happens when those markets are closed, delayed, or disrupted.

So the real policy question is larger than whether blockchain systems can process transactions at any hour. It's whether the whole setup - issuers, trading venues, custody, pricing mechanisms, and regulators - can handle stress consistently. A ledger can stay online, but that doesn't magically create liquidity or settle disputes about investor rights.

The institutional activity around the report suggests tokenization is moving beyond isolated crypto experiments. The NYSE plans to reach crypto investors through Blockchain.com, and its owner ICE is working with OKX on 24/7 tokenized stock trading under a new SEC innovation exemption. Securitize has brought tokenized stocks - including Nvidia, Apple, and Amazon - to Solana, with additional networks planned. Cboe has struck an S&P deal for tokenized options, and Coinbase launched tokenized stocks for non-U.S. users on Base in August.

These efforts aren't all the same product, and they don't prove the IMF's concerns are already solved. They do show major market operators and crypto firms are trying different paths into tokenization. The test isn't whether a big name is involved. The test is whether the product's legal rights, pricing, liquidity, and safeguards are clear - and whether they hold up under pressure.

A practical framework for evaluating the next launch

For investors, product teams, and regulators, a sensible evaluation flow looks like this:

  1. Define the asset and claim. Is the token direct ownership or price exposure? Who is legally responsible to the holder?
  2. Map the market. Where does trading occur, what are the normal liquidity conditions, and how does pricing work outside stock-market hours?
  3. Test the failure cases. What happens during a sharp price move, a venue outage, a redemption problem, or a disruption to the underlying market?
  4. Check the protections. Which rules apply, who supervises the relevant parties, and what recourse does a customer have?
  5. Compare convenience with cost. Does 24/7 access or fractional trading solve a real user problem once spreads, fees, and counterparty risks are included?

As a test, this beats asking whether a product is "onchain." The blockchain is only one piece. Market quality and investor outcomes depend on the rest of the system.

Conclusion: treat access as a feature, not proof of safety

The IMF's findings point to real interest in tokenized stocks. People are trading outside U.S. market hours, and most trades in the sample are smaller than a full share. It also shows an unfinished market. Tokenized equities were more volatile and less liquid than the stocks they tracked, and the market stayed small and concentrated.

For investors, the practical approach is to confirm what a token represents, how it trades when the underlying market is closed, and what protections apply before focusing on convenience. For market operators and regulators, the priority is getting pricing, liquidity, and safeguards to work in a 24/7 setup - not just extending the hours.

Tokenization can improve access and market infrastructure. It doesn't remove the need to understand the asset or manage risk. Before trading, read the product terms and compare the actual trading conditions with the conventional alternative.

Frequently Asked Questions

Tokenized stocks are blockchain-based tokens designed to track or provide exposure to publicly traded shares. Their legal structure varies. Some provide price exposure without direct ownership of the underlying shares, so investors should check the product terms rather than assume they hold conventional stock.
The IMF found that more than half of trading in the tokenized equities it studied occurred outside regular US market hours, and about 80% of trades involved less than one share. The tokens were also about 1.5 times more volatile and less liquid than the underlying stocks.
In the IMF’s study of five relatively liquid tokenized US equities, the tokens were roughly 1.5 times more volatile than their underlying stocks. The result describes that sample and period; it should not be treated as a guarantee about every tokenized stock or future market conditions.
Not necessarily. The IMF described the products it studied as synthetic tokens offering price exposure without direct share ownership. Rights depend on the specific product’s legal terms, so check whether it provides voting rights, dividend entitlements or a direct claim to shares.
No. A token can be available to trade while the underlying stock market is closed, but trading availability does not guarantee buyers, sellers or a narrow spread. The IMF found lower liquidity in tokenized equities, particularly on decentralized exchanges.

Related articles